Skip to content
Comparisons

Sweeteners, side by side

Honest, head-to-head comparisons of the sweeteners people actually choose between in the supermarket aisle. Facts, not health-blog folklore.

Sugar vs Honey
  • Both are primarily simple sugars. Sugar is sucrose; honey is roughly 40% fructose, 30% glucose, and water.
  • Honey has slightly more calories per teaspoon (around 21 kcal) than sugar (around 16 kcal) because it is denser.
  • Honey contains trace enzymes, antioxidants, and minerals, but in very small amounts.
  • Sugar dissolves cleanly in recipes; honey adds moisture and a distinct flavour.
  • Substitution rule of thumb: use 3/4 cup honey per 1 cup sugar, and reduce other liquids in the recipe.
Raw sugar vs White sugar
  • Raw sugar retains some molasses; white sugar has had all molasses removed through refining.
  • Calorie content is nearly identical between the two.
  • Raw sugar has a slightly more complex flavour due to residual molasses.
  • Raw sugar has larger crystals and may not dissolve as readily in cold liquids.
  • The colour difference is purely about processing, not about being more or less natural.
Cane sugar vs Beet sugar
  • Once fully refined, cane and beet sugar are chemically identical (both pure sucrose).
  • The source plants are different: sugarcane is a tropical grass, sugar beet is a temperate-climate root vegetable.
  • Differences only appear in raw or unrefined forms and in trace flavour compounds.
  • Zimbabwe produces cane sugar exclusively.
  • Globally, about 80% of sugar comes from sugarcane and 20% from sugar beet.
Brown sugar vs Muscovado
  • Brown sugar is typically refined white sugar with added molasses.
  • Muscovado is unrefined or partially refined with naturally retained molasses.
  • Muscovado has a stronger, more complex flavour and a stickier, moister texture.
  • Both can be substituted for each other in most recipes, with muscovado giving a more pronounced caramel note.
  • Muscovado is often associated with rum-style and dark-spiced bakes.
Sugar vs Artificial sweeteners
  • Artificial sweeteners (aspartame, sucralose, stevia, saccharin) provide sweetness with few or no calories.
  • They do not caramelise, which limits their use in baking.
  • Major regulatory bodies (FDA, EFSA, WHO) consider approved artificial sweeteners safe at recommended levels.
  • Taste differs: some people detect aftertastes with artificial sweeteners.
  • Sugar provides bulk, texture, and browning in cooking that sweeteners cannot replicate.
The bigger picture

All sweeteners, in proportion

The differences between sweeteners are usually smaller than marketing makes them sound. Once a sugar enters your bloodstream, your body handles glucose and fructose the same way regardless of source. The choice between sweeteners is mostly about flavour, baking behaviour, and personal preference.

Where to next?

For the technical breakdown of each type, see types of sugar. For nutrition specifics, see sugar and nutrition. To use these in actual recipes, see sugar in the kitchen.